Skip to main content

Captive freedom: Retail investors, financial subjectivities and real estate assets under platform logic

Date:
Location:
Chemistry Physics Building Room 222
Speaker(s) / Presenter(s):
Desiree Fields

Investment platforms have proliferated, spreading narratives, expectations, and practices of financial freedom and security. Platforms that facilitate real estate investment by ordinary people are a key site where financial subjectivities and individual capital become algorithmically networked to wider capitalist dynamics, within and beyond housing markets. Yet little is known about the geographically dispersed, atomized users who seek to secure financial futures through platform real estate investment. We address this challenge with an innovative methodology to examine how platforms mediate financial subjectivities and real estate. Our approach combines computational and textual analysis with in-depth qualitative study of a large corpus of conversations from a Reddit community dedicated to Fundrise, a major US investment platform. We find retail investors navigate both platforms to co-create networked financial subjectivity. Weaving polarized feelings with financial knowledge, they define financial goals and collective values through dynamics of in- and out-grouping and attempt to make sense of and frame real estate as an asset class. Countering wealth-tech’s narrative of democratization, we argue ordinary investors are unevenly captive to platform logic, attempting to negotiate a space for financial agency in a context of automation, stratification of users, and shifting digital and financial architectures. Seeking financial freedom, users construct their sense of proper financial subjectivity, struggling with and constrained by the platform’s own terms.

Desiree Fields is Associate Professor of Geography at UC Berkeley. She is an economic geographer and critical urban scholar. Her research program addresses how Wall Street and Silicon Valley are jointly transforming property relations, urbanization, and economic subjectivity. She has published widely in leading human geography and urban studies journals, including Annals of the American Association of GeographersProgress in Human Geography, Environment and Planning A, and Urban Studies. Dr. Fields was a fellow of the Swedish Collegium for Advanced Study in 2023-24. She is a trustee of the Urban Studies Foundation and an editor at Environment and Planning A and Housing, Theory, and Society.